In this video, the author said every great
thing comes from exploration and accumulation. Something new will be created
when the accumulation has reached a limit value of the maker. Everything human
created is from life. Learning and reference will make the life more colourful
and enrich.
A point is never changed; studying and
reference allow people to progress. I understand the progress of mankind is
learning knowledge from others. In this video the author exclaims, "It is
not fair for someone who invents something then other people just copy it and
spend less time developing the same works". Inventors and developers feel
very angry when others copy their work, but a strange thing is they themselves
copy from others.
Of course,
vicious plagiarism with benign reference can be distinguished. We clearly know
The Intellectual Property Right is encouraging people to created and use the
common culture of mankind. (From the last paragraph which is a discussion of
intellectual property rights in this video.) But the plagiarisers are contrary
to this point for their own benefit. The advantage of copied products is they
suppress original work, and keeps costs low for making their own work. This
could be detrimental to the original work and make sales decline. That's a
short-term benefit for the plagiarisers, but it may hurt the industry very
badly. There even have been some companies who buyout original designer's work
and take profits from other creators just because the creators use similar
ideas for their work. This event made many excellent designs go into a limbo
area and become a money tool. This video shows me that the human element is
difficult to change their complacency and possessiveness, so legal measures
introduced improve the relevant laws to limit this. But the abysmal expansion
for the Intellectual Property Treaty is also contrary to the original intention
of its creation. It negates the common sense of people’s mutual influence
together; some people pay a lot of money to make sure the common culture is
protected by law, which also deters creation.
The combination
and transformation of existing things is a kind of `creative training `which
can help people to create new value. I think an excellent invention cannot just
be a simply ‘copy’, but the progress based on improvement the accumulation of
all previous knowledge.
[See the video
above for more information]
After that, I
quickly looked at others audiences. (https://vimeo.com/139094998) Most of the
audience (including me) expressed understanding and recognition of such
explanations. But there are also some personal questioning comments, such as:
‘Balazs Benke (4
months ago): There is this movie from a hungarian director made only by cuts
from other movies. It's pretty amazing to see in one movie that as this video
said, we are using and mixing the same memes, topics during centuries to tell
stories. And what really correlates with the end of this video, that it cannot
be watched anywhere because it comprises hundreds of parts of different movies,
thus it violates copyrights. vsimeo.com/71065220 ’
‘Steven Nagy (1 year ago): So is Capitalism
the problem stating back as far as the revolutionary war? It seems like the
greed to claim ownership is more important than sharing great work. Love the
video, but didn't attempt to tell us how others are attempting to solve the
problem. Rather, it just copied, transformed and combined the same question and
threw it back at us.’
I personally think that this phenomenon is not unreasonable. After all,
some people cannot completely accept everything. They may think no matter how
conscious; some theorem will overturn in the future. Such as Stephen William
Hawking's paradox change his own theory. Or Nikolaj Kopernik said the earth
revolves around the sun. Or even more distant period people trust the earth is
square.
—— The man who has
made up his mind to win will never say ‘Impossible’. (Napoléon Bonaparte,)
没有评论:
发表评论